Business
How to Hire a Product Designer at a Startup
Renata Kobayashi3 min read
To hire a product designer at a startup, decide first whether you need a generalist who can do research, UX and visual design end to end, then review portfolios for real product problems solved (not just polished screens), run a short design exercise or a portfolio deep dive, and test how they collaborate with engineers and product. For a first designer, product thinking and range matter more than one specialty.
This guide covers what to look for, how to evaluate portfolios and how to run the interview.
TL;DR
- A first designer should usually be a generalist: research, UX, UI and some systems thinking.
- Review portfolios for problems, decisions and outcomes, not just visuals.
- Use a portfolio deep dive or a short, paid exercise, not unpaid spec work.
- Test collaboration with engineering and product.
- Hire for product thinking: can they decide what to build, not only how it looks?
What Kind of Designer Do You Need?
| Type | Strengths | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Product designer (generalist) | Research, flows, UI, prototyping | First or second designer |
| UX designer | Research, information architecture, usability | Complex workflows |
| Visual or brand designer | Visual identity, marketing design | Brand and marketing needs |
| Design systems designer | Components, consistency at scale | Larger product teams |
How Should You Review a Portfolio?
For each case study, look for:
- The problem: what was broken or missing, and for whom?
- Their role: what did they personally decide and do?
- The process: research, options considered, trade-offs.
- The outcome: what changed for users or the business?
Beautiful screens with no problem or outcome are a yellow flag for a startup role.
How Should You Interview?
- Portfolio deep dive (60 minutes): one case study in depth, with follow-up questions.
- Collaboration session: work through a real product problem with an engineer and a PM.
- Short, paid exercise if you need more signal; never ask for unpaid work on your real product.
“Walk me through a decision in this project you’d make differently today, and why.”
How Can Refer’s Lia Help?
Lia, Refer’s AI recruiter, works on design roles too: she checks each candidate’s experience against your requirements and introduces designers who already said yes to your role.
- Free for companies: no contract, subscription or placement fee.
- Double opt-in introductions.
- Extra requirements: add private criteria, like B2B or mobile experience.
- Proven: more than 5,000 introductions.
How-To: Hire a Product Designer in 5 Steps
- Pick the type. Usually a generalist for the first hire.
- Write three or four must-haves. Including product thinking.
- Review portfolios for outcomes. Problem, role, decisions, results.
- Run a deep dive and a collaboration session. Paid exercise only if needed.
- Check references on collaboration. With engineers and PMs.
Focused FAQ
What should I look for in a startup’s first product designer?
Range across research, UX and UI, strong product thinking and comfort working closely with engineering.
Should I give designers a take-home exercise?
A portfolio deep dive often gives enough signal. If you need an exercise, keep it short and pay for it.
How do I evaluate a design portfolio?
Look for the problem, the designer’s role, the decisions made and the outcome, not just the visuals.
About the Author
Renata is on the founding team at Refer.