Blog
Visit Refer

Business

How to Hire a Product Designer at a Startup

Renata Kobayashi3 min read

How to Hire a Product Designer at a Startup

To hire a product designer at a startup, decide first whether you need a generalist who can do research, UX and visual design end to end, then review portfolios for real product problems solved (not just polished screens), run a short design exercise or a portfolio deep dive, and test how they collaborate with engineers and product. For a first designer, product thinking and range matter more than one specialty.

This guide covers what to look for, how to evaluate portfolios and how to run the interview.


TL;DR

  • A first designer should usually be a generalist: research, UX, UI and some systems thinking.
  • Review portfolios for problems, decisions and outcomes, not just visuals.
  • Use a portfolio deep dive or a short, paid exercise, not unpaid spec work.
  • Test collaboration with engineering and product.
  • Hire for product thinking: can they decide what to build, not only how it looks?

What Kind of Designer Do You Need?

TypeStrengthsBest for
Product designer (generalist)Research, flows, UI, prototypingFirst or second designer
UX designerResearch, information architecture, usabilityComplex workflows
Visual or brand designerVisual identity, marketing designBrand and marketing needs
Design systems designerComponents, consistency at scaleLarger product teams

How Should You Review a Portfolio?

For each case study, look for:

  • The problem: what was broken or missing, and for whom?
  • Their role: what did they personally decide and do?
  • The process: research, options considered, trade-offs.
  • The outcome: what changed for users or the business?

Beautiful screens with no problem or outcome are a yellow flag for a startup role.


How Should You Interview?

  • Portfolio deep dive (60 minutes): one case study in depth, with follow-up questions.
  • Collaboration session: work through a real product problem with an engineer and a PM.
  • Short, paid exercise if you need more signal; never ask for unpaid work on your real product.

“Walk me through a decision in this project you’d make differently today, and why.”


How Can Refer’s Lia Help?

Lia, Refer’s AI recruiter, works on design roles too: she checks each candidate’s experience against your requirements and introduces designers who already said yes to your role.

  • Free for companies: no contract, subscription or placement fee.
  • Double opt-in introductions.
  • Extra requirements: add private criteria, like B2B or mobile experience.
  • Proven: more than 5,000 introductions.

Start hiring with Lia.


How-To: Hire a Product Designer in 5 Steps

  1. Pick the type. Usually a generalist for the first hire.
  2. Write three or four must-haves. Including product thinking.
  3. Review portfolios for outcomes. Problem, role, decisions, results.
  4. Run a deep dive and a collaboration session. Paid exercise only if needed.
  5. Check references on collaboration. With engineers and PMs.

Focused FAQ

What should I look for in a startup’s first product designer?

Range across research, UX and UI, strong product thinking and comfort working closely with engineering.

Should I give designers a take-home exercise?

A portfolio deep dive often gives enough signal. If you need an exercise, keep it short and pay for it.

How do I evaluate a design portfolio?

Look for the problem, the designer’s role, the decisions made and the outcome, not just the visuals.


About the Author

Renata is on the founding team at Refer.


Sources