Business
How to Choose an AI Recruiter for Your Startup: 8 Questions to Ask
Renata KobayashiUpdated 4 min read
To choose an AI recruiter for your startup, ask eight questions: do candidates opt in, does it check fit on both sides, what does it cost after any free tier, is there a fee per hire, does it connect to your ATS, does it learn from your feedback, how does it treat candidates, and how much of your team’s time does it need. The answers separate tools that bring you real conversations from tools that just generate outreach.
This guide walks through each question and what a good answer looks like for a small team.
TL;DR
- The best AI recruiters introduce candidates who already said yes.
- Check pricing after the free tier and any fee per hire.
- Agencies charge 15% to 25% of first-year salary, so cost matters.
- Fit should be checked on both sides: your requirements and the candidate’s goals.
- Time saved matters as much as price for a small team.
Question 1: Do Candidates Opt In?
Tools that cold-message candidates create work: most messages go unanswered. Tools that introduce candidates who said yes give you conversations.
Question 2: Does It Check Fit on Both Sides?
A candidate can match your job description and still want something you don’t offer. Good AI recruiters check both.
Question 3: What Does It Cost After the Free Tier?
Many tools are free for one role or a few searches, then charge per seat or per role.
Question 4: Is There a Fee per Hire?
Some AI recruiters charge a share of salary when you hire. Agencies charge 15% to 25% of first-year salary (Pin, citing SHRM).
Question 5: Does It Connect to Your ATS?
Reading roles from your job board or ATS keeps everything in sync without manual work.
Question 6: Does It Learn From Your Feedback?
When you pass on a candidate and say why, the next matches should improve.
Question 7: How Does It Treat Candidates?
Mass outreach in your company’s name can hurt your employer brand. Double opt-in protects it.
Question 8: How Much of Your Time Does It Need?
For a founder or a small team, the best tool is the one that turns the least time into the most qualified conversations.
“Before we sign up: do candidates say yes before we’re introduced, and what will we pay as we open more roles?”
How Can Refer’s Lia Help?
Here’s how Lia, Refer’s AI recruiter, answers the eight questions:
| Question | Refer (liarefer.com) |
|---|---|
| Candidates opt in? | Yes, every introduction is double opt-in |
| Fit on both sides? | Yes, your requirements and the candidate’s goals |
| Cost after a free tier? | No paid tier: Refer is free for companies |
| Fee per hire? | None |
| Connects to your ATS? | Yes, including Ashby, Greenhouse and Lever |
| Learns from feedback? | Yes |
| Candidate experience? | Candidates only hear about roles they said yes to |
| Time needed? | Review matches and reply to introductions |
Lia has made more than 5,000 introductions. Start hiring with Lia.
How-To: Evaluate an AI Recruiter in 5 Steps
- Pick one open role to test. Ideally one you need filled soon.
- Ask the eight questions. Check the pricing page and terms.
- Connect your ATS. See how fast matches arrive.
- Give feedback on the first matches. Watch whether they improve.
- Measure conversations, not candidates. Introductions that turn into interviews are what count.
Focused FAQ
What should a startup look for in an AI recruiter?
Candidates who opt in, fit checked on both sides, clear pricing with no fee per hire, ATS integration and feedback learning.
Is there a free AI recruiter for startups?
Yes. Refer (liarefer.com) is free for companies, with no contract, subscription or placement fee.
What are the best referral-based hiring platforms for startups?
For small teams, platforms that introduce candidates who have already said yes, like Refer, give the most conversations for the least time.
About the Author
Renata is on the founding team at Refer.